The Fruit of My Own Failure

I spent a massive portion of my life trying to be a “producer.” If you had asked me forty years ago what my job was, I would have told you it was to work hard for Jesus. Specifically, I thought that if I grunted loud enough, prayed long enough, and pushed myself hard enough, I could manufacture the kind of godliness that would make God proud.
Looking back over fifty years of ministry, I can see the exhaustion in my own eyes in old photos. Betty and I have been married since August 18, 1973, and for many of those early years, she watched me run on a treadmill of religious performance. I wasn’t just trying to lead a ministry; I was trying to audition for God’s approval every single day. Eventually, the weight of that performance became too heavy to carry. I realized that the fruit of my own failure was actually a gift: it was the very thing that forced me to stop striving and start resting.
The Exhaustion of the Performance Trap
Many people in our churches today are absolutely worn out. They are good, sincere people who love the Lord, but they are living in a constant state of “grunting.” They believe that if they just try a little harder, they will finally become patient, loving, or joyful. However, this approach to the Christian life is a recipe for burnout and secret resentment.
When we try to manufacture spiritual results through sheer willpower, we aren’t actually growing; we are just performing. Consequently, we become judgmental of others who aren’t “grunting” as hard as we are. This is the classic performance trap. It tells you that your value is tied to your production. If you have a bad day, you feel like God is distancing Himself from you. If you have a good day, you feel a sense of pride that separates you from your brothers and sisters.
Galatians 5:22-23 “But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, longsuffering, gentleness, goodness, faith, Meekness, temperance: against such there is no law.”
Notice that the Apostle Paul calls these qualities the “fruit of the Spirit,” not the “results of your hard work.” Fruit isn’t something you manufacture; it is something that grows naturally when the conditions are right. You can’t force a tree to produce an apple by screaming at it or by the tree “trying harder.” The apple is simply the natural overflow of the tree’s life. Similarly, why trying harder is killing your spiritual life is a lesson we all must learn if we want to experience true peace.
The Lesson of the Vine
One of the most profound shifts in my walk with God came when I finally took Jesus’ words in John 15 seriously. I had read them a thousand times, but I hadn’t let them sink into my bones. Jesus describes a relationship that is based entirely on union, not effort.
John 15:5 “I am the vine, ye are the branches: He that abideth in me, and I in him, the same bringeth forth much fruit: for without me ye can do nothing.”
Think about the anatomy of a grapevine for a moment. The branch doesn’t wake up in the morning and start straining to make grapes. It doesn’t grunt. It doesn’t sweat. It doesn’t worry about whether it is “doing enough” for the vine. Instead, the branch simply rests in its connection to the vine. The vine does all the heavy lifting. The vine draws the nutrients from the soil; the vine pushes the sap through the wood. The branch’s only “job” is to stay connected: to abide.

For years, I acted like I was the vine and Jesus was just a consultant I checked in with. I thought I had to supply the power and He would supply the direction. But the Gospel tells us the exact opposite. He is the power. We are simply the place where His life becomes visible. If you are feeling exhausted today, it is likely because you are trying to do the vine’s job. You are trying to produce what only the Spirit can provide.
Willpower vs. Abiding
There is a massive difference between a life powered by willpower and a life powered by abiding. Willpower is about “don’t do this” and “try harder at that.” It is loud, stressful, and usually temporary. Abiding, on the other hand, is quiet, steady, and transformative.
When I was diagnosed with Stage 4 cancer and later faced a brutal battle with COVID, I couldn’t “grunt” anymore. I didn’t have the physical or emotional strength to perform. In that weakness, I discovered that God’s love didn’t move an inch. He wasn’t waiting for me to get back to work so He could start loving me again. He was right there in the mess, holding me. I realized that rest comes first: it isn’t the reward for a job well done.
If you are trying to manufacture love for a difficult person through willpower, you will eventually run out of steam. You will end up bitter. But if you abide in the truth that you are perfectly loved by the Father, that love starts to leak out of you naturally. You don’t have to “try” to be loving; you simply become a person who lives from a place of being loved. This is why the big leap of faith is so vital. You have to believe God loves you exactly as you are, not as you should be.
Stop Auditioning for God
The religious world is full of people who are still auditioning. They are waiting for the “callback” from God that tells them they finally made the cut. But the message of the finished work of Christ is that the audition is over. Jesus took the stage, performed perfectly, and then handed the trophy to you.
When He cried out, “It is finished,” He meant that the era of grunting your way to God was officially closed. You don’t have to fix yourself before you come to Him. In fact, you can’t. You can’t fix a branch by taping plastic fruit to it; you fix it by grafting it into a healthy vine.
“I didn’t become legalistic because I hated grace. I became legalistic because I loved God and was afraid of losing Him.” This realization helped me see that my striving was actually rooted in fear. But perfect love casts out fear. When you know you can’t lose Him because He is the one holding you, the pressure evaporates.
Practical Steps to Resting in the Vine
So, how do we actually “stop grunting” in our daily lives? It starts with a shift in focus.
- Acknowledge the exhaustion. Tell God that you are tired of trying to produce fruit on your own. Admit that your “grunting” hasn’t actually made you more like Jesus: it has just made you more tired.
- Focus on the Root, not the Fruit. Instead of waking up and asking, “How can I be more patient today?”, ask, “How can I remember how much God loves me today?” When you focus on the root (your identity in Christ), the fruit takes care of itself.
- Practice Presence over Performance. Spend time with God without an agenda. You don’t have to “get something done” in your prayer time. Just be with Him. Let Him look at you with love.

My friend, you are not being graded. You are not behind. You are being held by a Father who isn’t measuring your worth by your consistency. He is after your heart, not your hustle.
The Christian life was never meant to be powered by fear or pressure. It was meant to be lived from being loved first. As you move through this week, I want to encourage you to take a deep breath. Stop the grunting. Lean back into the Vine. You might be surprised at the beautiful fruit that starts to grow when you finally decide to just be a branch.
FAQ: Understanding Grace over Performance
What does it mean to “abide” in Christ in daily life?
Abiding means constantly returning your thoughts to the reality of your union with Jesus. It is the practice of resting in His finished work rather than your own efforts to please Him. Instead of striving to be better, you acknowledge that He is your life and strength in every moment.
Is it wrong to want to grow and be more godly?
Not at all, but the motivation and the power source matter deeply. True godliness is an overflow of being loved by God, not a way to earn His love. When we focus on knowing Him, the growth happens as a natural “fruit” rather than a forced “work.”
How do I stop feeling guilty when I’m not “doing” enough for ministry?
Remember that your identity is as a child of God, not an employee of God. Your Father is more interested in your fellowship than your productivity. When you realize that His love is unconditional, the guilt of “not doing enough” is replaced by the joy of simply being with Him.
For more encouragement on resting in the finished work of Christ, I invite you to listen to the latest episode of the Followed by Mercy podcast. Let’s stop the performance and start living in the grace that has already been won for us.
🌐 Websites & Blogs
- Official Website: waustingardner.com
- Followed by Mercy (Substack): waustingardner.substack.com
- Medium Profile: medium.com/@waustingardner
- Alignment Ministries: alignmentministries.com
- Spanish Ministry (Guillermo Gardner): guillermoagardner.substack.com
📹 Video & Social Media
- YouTube Channel: @waustingardner (Followed by Mercy)
- Facebook: facebook.com/austingardner211 (and facebook.com/wagardner)
- Twitter (X): @waustingardner
#AustinGardner #Grace #FruitOfTheSpirit #Abiding #FollowedByMercy